Prosecutor's office appealed acquittal of women human rights defenders in Kempir-Abad case

On 12 July 2024, the General prosecutor's office in Kyrgyzstan filed a second appeal against the Pervomaiskyi District Court's decision from 14 June 2024 on the Kempir-Abad case. In this decision, the Court acquitted and released women human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Asya Sasykbayeva, and other members of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad water reserve. The General prosecutor's office, in their second appeal, have requested the Bishkek City Court panel to overturn the acquittal decision and to find all members guilty.

Initially, on 28 June 2024, the General prosecutor's office requested that the Pervomaiskyi District Court reconsider the case with a different judicial composition.

The women human rights defenders were initially charged with “conspiring to organize mass riots” under Article 36-278 of the Criminal Code, when they were first detained in October 2022. In January 2023, they faced an additional aggravated charge of “forcible seizure of power” under Article 326. The prosecutor demanded 20 years of imprisonment and property confiscation as sanctions.

The women human rights defenders are now awaiting the dates for their new trial.

On 10 June 2024, within the trial against the representatvies of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad in Pervomaiskii District Court in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan, the Prosecutor requested 20 years of prison time for women human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva and Asya Sasykbayeva. The Prosecutor also requested to confiscate the entirety of the women human rights defender’s property, including their homes and personal belongings. All 27 members of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad face similar sentences.

Klara Sooronkulova is a woman human rights defender, chairwoman of the NGO “School of Law” and a chairwoman of the Committee to Protect Political Prisoners. Rita Karasartova is a woman human rights defender and an expert in civic governance. She works for the human rights organization and think tank, Institute of Civic Analysis. Gulnara Dzhurabayeva is a woman human rights defender, who has collaborated with “Interbilim” since 2020, and Asya Sasykbayeva is a founder and ex-head of the human rights organization “Interbilim.” Interbilim is an organization that sets out to promote the creation and effective functioning of democratic institutions, ensuring democratic governance, and transparency of the state system through the mechanisms of public examination and the monitoring of the activities of state bodies.

On 10 June 2024, human rights defenders from Kyrgyzstan reported that within the trial against the representatives of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad, ongoing since June 2023, the Prosecutor requested 20 years of prison time and confiscation of property for all representatives, including Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva and Asya Sasykbayeva. The women human rights defenders are being accused of “conspiring to organize mass riots” and of “forcible seizure of power”. These are both criminal offences envisioned respectively by Article 36-278 and Article 326 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan.

An almost a year-long trial in Pervomaiskii District Court in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan, has been classified, thus it is impossible to know what the grounds for such appaling sentences are. Kyrgyzstani human rights defenders have called the trial non-transparent, and the court alledgedly failed to properly review the case, as no evidentiary support was offered to back the conspiring and seizure of power claims.

The women human rights defenders were arrested in October 2022 together with 23 other activists and representatives of political parties, who peacefully opposed the transferring of the Kempir-Abad water reserve to Uzbekistan and called for transparency from the government of Kyrgyzstan about their agreement with Uzbekistan authorities. In November 2022, during their pre-trial detention, Klara Sooronkulova and Rita Karasartova engaged in a hunger strike to oppose their detention conditions. In February 2023, while in pre-trial detention, Klara Sooronkulova was hospitalized. In April 2023, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, and Asya Sasykbayeva were released from pre-trial detention under house arrest, after spending 7 months in pre-trial detention. In June 2023, the court released Rita Karasartova; she spend 9 months in pre-trial detention. After the release, all women human rigths defenders reported to have faced surveillance and censorship from the state authorities.

Fornt Line Defenders condemns the request to sentence women human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva and Asya Sasykbayeva to 20 years of prison time with property confiscation. Front Line Defenders urges the authorities of Kyrgyzstan to immediately and unconditionally drop all charges against Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, Gulnara Dzhurabayeva and Asya Sasykbayeva, as the organization believes that these charges are solely motivated by their peaceful and legitimate human rights work.

On 19 April 2023, Pervomayskii District Court of the City of Bishkek ruled to extend woman human rights defender Rita Karasartova’s pre-trial detention until 20 June 2023. She is the only woman human rights defender detained in response to the work of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad water reserve who remains in pre-trial detention. On 12 April 2023, women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, and Asya Sasykbayeva were released from pre-trial detention under house arrest, but will still face trial.

Rita Karasartova is a woman human rights defender and an expert in civic governance. She works for the human rights organisation and think tank, Institute of Civic Analysis. Klara Sooronkulova is a woman human rights defender, chairwoman of the NGO “School of Law” and a chairwoman of the Committee to Protect Political Prisoners. Gulnara Dzhurabayeva is a woman human rights defender, who has collaborated with the human rights organisation “Interbilim” since 2020, and Asya Sasykbayeva is a founder and former head of “Interbilim.”

On 19 April 2023, Pervomayskii District Court ruled to extend woman human rights defender Rita Karasartova’s pre-trial detention until 20 June 2023. The hearing concerning the fate of Rita Karasartova started on 18 April 2023, yet, the decision was only announced the next day. On 12 April 2023, Pervomayskii district Court of the City of Bishkek ruled to release women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, and Asya Sasykbayeva from their pre-trial detention and place them under house arrest, however, they still will face trial. Moreover, on 14 March 2023 Bishkek City Court partially removed the classified status from the Kempir-Abad-related case file, which had been fully classified since January 2023. This decision allowed the recent court hearings to be open to the public.

Woman human rights defender Rita Karasarkova’s health has severly deteriorated since she was placed in detention in October 2022. Her daughter recently stated in her social media post that the conditions of the Pre-trial Detention Center #1, where Rita Karasartova is held, are absolutely inhuman. She said that since the pre-trial detention is a facility that is designed for temporary placement, it is not suitable or equipped for long-term detention. The detention center authorities refuse woman human rights defender her visitation rights; she also can’t use the phone to call her relatives. In June 2023 Rita Karasartova will have spent eight months in detention.

On 24 October 2022, Kyrgyzstani law enforcement officers arbitrarily arrested and detained women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, and Asya Sasykbayeva for their peaceful protest against transferring ownership of the Kempir-Abad water reserve from Kyrgyzstan to Uzbekistan. The women human rights defenders are being accused of conspiring to organise mass riots, a criminal offense envisioned by Article 36-278 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan. If charged, the women human rights defenders may face up to 10 years in prison. They are among 24 other activists and representatives of political parties who peacefully opposed transferring the Kempir-Abad water reserve to Uzbekistan and who called for the government of Kyrgyzstan to be transparent about their agreement with the Uzbekistan authorities. On 17 November 2022, the Kempir-Abad water reserve was transferred to Uzbekistan.

Front Line Defenders is gravely concerned about the extention of the term of pre-trial detention for a woman human rights defender Rita Karasartova, and calls for her immediate and unconditional release. Front Line defenders also expresses serious concerns about the conditions of Rita Karasartova’s pre-trial detention and the limitation of her visitation rights. Front Line Defenders welcomes the authorities’ decision to release woman human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, and Asya Sasykbayeva from pre-trial detention, however, condemns their placement under house arrest and calls for their immediate and unconditional aqquittal. In light of the recent developments, Front Line Defenders reiterates its call to immediately and unconditionally release all representatives of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad water reseve and to drop all charges against them as it believes that these are solely motivated by their peaceful human rights work.

On 17 February 2023, Pervomaisky District Court of the city of Bishkek in Kyrsgyzstan extended the pre-trial detention of women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova and Asya Sasykbayeva. The women human rights defenders will now remain in pre-trial detention until 20 April 2023.

Klara Sooronkulova is a woman human rights defender, chairwoman of the NGO “School of Law” and a chairwoman of the Committee to Protect Political Prisoners. Rita Karasartova is a woman human rights defender and an expert in civic governance. She works for the human rights organization and think tank, Institute of Civic Analysis. Gulnara Dzhurabayeva is a woman human rights defender, who has collaborated with “Interbilim” since 2020, and Asya Sasykbayeva is a founder and ex-head of the human rights organization “Interbilim.” Interbilim is an organization that sets out to promote the creation and effective functioning of democratic institutions, ensuring democratic governance, and transparency of the state system through the mechanisms of public examination and the monitoring of the activities of state bodies.

On 17 February 2023, Pervomaisky District Court of the city of Bishkek extended the pre-trial detention of women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova and Asya Sasykbayeva. The women human rights defenders, all of whom were arrested and placed in pre-trial detention on 24 October 2022, will now remain in detention until 20 April 2023. Earlier, on 18 January 2023, the Head of the Investigative task force working on the criminal case against the members of the Committere to Protect Kempir-Abad, informed the defence attorneys that the case was classified. The Ministry of Interior of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan didn’t provide any justification to the lawyers and defendents as to why this was the case.

On 10 February 2023, colleagues of woman human rights defender Klara Sooronkulova shared that she is facing additional charges for reposting a Facebook post that was part of the campaign “#kamasanarbaarybyzdykamagyla,” translates: “if you put him in jail, put us all in jail.” The campaign was designed to protest the February 2022 arrest of political activist Mirlan Uraimov. In February 2022 when the woman human rights defender re-posted the aforementioned post, the State Committee for National Security of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan initiated a legal expert review of the post. Despite the fact that the results of the expertise stated there was no basis for criminal charges, Klara Sooronkulova faced persecution for the same Facebook post, charged with conspiring to organize mass riots, a criminal offense envisioned by Article 36-278 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan. Her colleagues suggest that these charges are related to the wider persecution of the members of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad.

On 10 January 2023, Bishkek law enforcement officers detained 30 peaceful protesters, who called for an immediate release of all the activists, journalists, and human rights defenders from the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad water reserve. The police pushed the protesters away from the building of the Ministry of interior, where the peaceful demonstration commenced. After the protest moved to the Gorky Square, the police officers continued to harras the protesters, forcing them to hide their posters that called for an immediate release of the members of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad. Mostly the protesters were friends and family of those in pre-trial detention; all the protesters were released the same day.

On 24 October 2022, Kyrgyzstani law enforcement officers arbitrarily arrested and detained women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, and Asya Sasykbayeva for their peaceful protest against transferring ownership of the Kempir-Abad water reserve from Kyrgyzstan to Uzbekistan. The women human rights defenders are being accused of conspiring to organize mass riots, a criminal offense envisioned by Article 36-278 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan. If charged, the women human rights defenders may face up to 10 years in prison. They are among 24 other activists and representatives of political parties who peacefully opposed transferring the Kempir-Abad water reserve to Uzbekistan and who called for the government of Kyrgyzstan to be transparent about their agreement with the Uzbekistan authorities. On 14 November 2022, women human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova and Rita Karasartova began a hunger strike in opposition to the decision of the Pervomaisky District Court; the hunger stike ended at the end of December 2022. On 17 November 2022, the Kempir-Abad water reserve was transferred to Uzbekistan.

Front Line Defenders condemns yet another extension of the pre-trial detention term of the women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova and Asya Sasykbayeva, who were a part of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad. Front Line Defenders expresses its grave concerns at the Ministry of Interior’s decision to keep the case against the members of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad classified. Front Line Defenders urges the authorities of Kyrgyzstan to immediately release women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova and Asya Sasykbayeva, as well as other members of Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad, and drop all charges against them, as it believes that these are solely motivated by their peaceful human rights work.

On 11 November 2022, Bishkek City Court rejected the appeal to change the interim measure from detention to house arrest for woman human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova and Asya Sasykbayeva. The same occurred on 10 November 2022 for woman human rights defender Rita Karasartova, and on 9 November 2022 for woman human rights defender Gulnara Dzhurabayeva.

Download the Urgent Appeal

Klara Sooronkulova is a woman human rights defenders, chairwoman of the NGO “School of Law” and a chairwoman of the Committee to Protect Political Prisoners. WHRD carries out out systematic monitoring of trials of political prisoners, work on the issues of freedom of speech, judicial reforms, and corruption. She vocally opposed laws on social media censorship and the Russia copy-cat foreign agents law.

Rita Karasartova is a woman human rights defender and an expert in civic governance. She works for the Institute of Civic Analysis, a human rights organization and a think tank. The organization works to monitor the selection and rotation process within the Kyrgyzstani judiciary system. The woman human rights defender also supports provides independent legal expertese to the local participatory governments. Rita Karasartova is one of the first women human rights defenders, who started publically covering issues within in the law enforcement and judiciary systems in Kyrgyz language.

Gulnara Dzhurabayeva is a woman human rights defender, who collaborated with “Interbilim” since 2020, and Asya Sasykbayeva is a founder and ex-head of human rights organization “Interbilim.” Interbilim is an organization that is set out to promote the creation and effective functioning of democratic institutions, ensuring democratic governance, and transparency of the state system through the mechanisms of public examination and monitoring of the activities of state bodies.

The women human rights defenders appealed the decision of the Pervomayskii District Court of the City of Bishkek on 25 October 2022 to detain them for 2 months for their peaceful protest against the transferring the ownership of the Kempir-Abad water reserve from Kyrgyzstan to Uzbekistan. Klara Sooronkulova, Asya Sasykbayeva, Rita Karasartova, and Gulnara Dzhurabayeva will remain in detention until 20 December 2022. The women human rights defenders are being accused of conspiring to organize mass riots, a criminal offense envisioned by Article 36-278 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan. If charged, the women human rights defenders can face up to 10 years of prison time. The Court refused to take into account that two women human rights defenders have young children and two women human rights defenders are over 60 years old. Some of their colleagues, who are detained in Temporary Isolation Ward #1 of the City of Bishkek, report that the detention conditions are very poor and the incarceration units lack proper heating.

On 24 October 2022, Kyrgyzstani law enforcement officers arbitrary arrested and detained women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, and Asya Sasykbayeva for their peaceful protest against the tranferring the ownership of the Kempir-Abad water reserve from Kyrgyzstan to Uzbekistan. They were among 24 other activists and representatives of political parties, who peacefully opposed the transferring of the Kempir-Abad water reserve to Uzbekistan, stating that Kempir-Abad is an important source of pottable water for the local comunities, and that the transfering of the reservoir to Uzbekistan will affect local farmers who will be forcefully displaced in Uzbekistan.

On 22 October 2022, human rights defenders, local activists, journalists, and political actors established a Committee to protect the Kempir-Abad in opposing the transfering of the water reservoir from Kyrgyzstan to Uzbekistan. The Committee was set up as a result of public convening of local communities dwelling the premises of the Kempir-Abad on 15 October 2022, where representatives of the local communities called upon the Kyrgyztani government to stop the transferring of the water reservoir and the exchange of territories between Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan. On 21 October 2022, in Uzgen District of the Osh region, representatives of the local communities affected by the transferring of the Kempir-Abad reserve from villages of Kurshab and Kyzyl-Oktyabr held a peaceful march.

On 23 October 2022, premises of homes of representatives of the Committee to Protect Kempir-Abad in Bishkek and Osh were raided by various Ministry of Interior authorities, and personal equipment was ceised during the raids. On 24 October 2022, twenty-four representatives of the Committee, including women human rights defenders Gulnara Dzhurabayeva, Klara Sooronkulova, Rita Karasartova, and Asya Sasykbayeva, were arbirtary detained and on 25 October 2022, sentenced to 2 months of pre-trial detention.

Front Line Defenders is gravely concerned about the detention of women human rights defenders Klara Sooronkulova, Asya Sasykbayeva, Rita Karasartova, and Gulnara Dzhurabayeva and considers this detention as a retaliation against their peaceful human rights work and public criticism of the decision to transfer the Kempir-Abad reservoir to Uzbekistan. The detention of the women human rights defenders is part of the escalating persecution of human rights defenders in Kyrgyzstan and their increasing censorship.